Bonavita vs Technivorm – 2 Great Coffee Makers, Head to Head - HOMEGROUNDS
3

Bonavita vs Technivorm Moccamaster – 2 Great Coffee Makers, Head to Head

Not all coffee makers are created equal and this definitely rings true when you ask coffee nerds and brew aficionados about automatic drip coffee machines. Some are pure and utter s**t, but some are surprisingly good (We are talking about automatic drip machines, not manual drippers)

There is an abundance of automatic coffee makers on the market, but when it comes to the most popular ones, it’s often a hard choice between The Bonavita vs Technivorm.

Thinking of buying either of the two? Of course you are – why else would you be reading this? Make sure the showdown below to find out how these two fare when it comes to ease of use, style, brewing performance, and the resulting brew.​

Bonavita BV1800SS 8-Cup Original Coffee Brewer, Stainless Steel

The Bonavita Dripper

The popularity of the Bonavita among coffee enthusiasts cannot be denied. It’s one-button operation combined with the quality of your final brew means it gives you the best of both worlds: its easy to use, and it doesn’t sacrifice on quality.

It comes with a number of features that drip coffee lovers rave about, one of which is its large shower head, which helps you wet your grounds more evenly, and enables better extraction. You’ll get the most out of your coffee grounds.

The 1500-watt heater helps you reach the ideal water temperature of 195 to 205 degrees, and its thermal carafe keeps your brew pleasantly hot for longer. There is nothing worse than having to rush your coffee out of fear of it becoming cold (and hence, bitter)

The Technivorm Moccamaster

The Technivorm is loved for its reliability, which can be credited to its solid structure and simple, user-friendly design.

It features a stainless steel carafe with a funneled lip, which makes for easy pouring.The material used also helps keep your brew steamy up to six hours, allowing you to enjoy hot coffee for most of your day without the need to re-brew.

But its more aesethetics; the Technivorm delivers best in terms of providing you the ideal temperature for extracting your coffee throughout the entire brewing process. You’ll also enjoy brew time of less than six minutes, with a serving of up to 10 cups at a time!

Yes, it may be one of the more expensive automatic drip coffee makers at $300, but the Technivorm delivers such smooth, almost-velvety coffee that java lovers believe it’s worth the investment (we do, at least)​

The Showdown: Bonavita vs. Technivorm

Since you’re ready to spend a few hundred dollars for a good automated brewer, might as well make sure you choose the cream of the crop, right? You’re about to discover whether the Bonavita or the Technivorm is right for you, in terms of convenience, design, performance, and the resulting brew.

It’s worth nothing that these two are certified by the SCAA (Specialty Coffee Association of America), the world’s largest organisation of coffee experts. This means they’ve passed a rigorous set of tests in terms of structure and performance – so there is no bad choice in the end.​

1. Ease of use

The Bonavita proudly showcases a one-button operation system, just set up your water compartment, filter, and your coffee grounds, press the ‘on’ button, and you’re good to go. It also has an auto-off feature which activates after 15 minutes. This feature lets you save on electric consumption, and helps ensure that your brew does not end up over-extracted.

Its showerhead, which comes with an efficient set of holes, enables it to evenly wet your coffee grounds without intervention. This way, you get the most flavor from the beans into your brew, minus the need to exert time and effort in stirring your ground coffee.

The Technivorm is designed to be just as simple to operate, and also features a safety switch which ceases operation when your carafe is not positioned correctly.

This coffee maker’s showerhead can also be rotated manually, which may take a bit of effort, but does help in ensuring that the grounds get an even extraction. You can find some basic operation tips and tricks for Technivorm in this video:​

Clean-up is another matter altogether. The Bonavita DOES have a well-designed showerhead, but it also pose’s a problem when it comes to cleanup. The Technivorm on the other hand has a removable showerhead, which is 10x easier to clean.

WINNER - The Bonavita wins this category even though it’s a really close fight. It's easy to operate, and though there may be a slight hiccup in cleaning the showerhead, it still makes for near-effortless brewing.


2. Style/Design

Aesthetics may not always matter in terms of coffee-making, but when it comes to Bonavita and Technivorm, this aspect is quite the equalizer.

The China-made Bonavita is a well-built coffee-making wonder which features a glass-lined thermal carafe that keeps its contents consistently hot.

The brew basket is of the Melitta brand, and features a closed design with vent holes. The design does not make it possible for you to stir the grounds during brewing, but it does help prevent steam from lingering inside the basket during the process.

The Technivorm on the other hand has a solid, all-metal carafe. This brewer also has a copper heating feature, which is said to do a more efficient job of getting and keeping the water to an ideal temperature.

Its brew basket is distinctive for its open design - allowing coffee enthusiasts to interfere with the brewing process when they wish to do so.​

WINNER - The Technivorm dominates the design category for its elegant lines, solid structure, and efficient brewing features.


3. Brewing Performance

With the Bonavita, you get the very essence of brewing in an easy to operate machine. In addition to the efficient showerhead, its brew basket also enables steam to escape so it does not go back into the filter basket, and affect the resulting taste of your brew.

You’ll also find its pre-infusion feature a great addition, enabling you to let your coffee ‘bloom’ and degas, before you proceed with brewing. This process helps prepare the grounds for more contact with water, and begins the release of flavor from your coffee.

You can easily activate this feature by pressing and holding the power switch for five seconds.

The Technivorm on the other hand, with its mostly metal parts, ensures that your water does not get in contact with plastic parts once it is boiled, to avoid potentially affecting your brew’s taste.

According to a test done with this brewer, it achieves and maintains temperature at 200 to 204 degrees during the entire brewing process - the ideal amount of heat to ensure even extraction.

Compared to other coffee makers, the Technivorm proves that it can produce consistently smooth cups of coffee, and maintain the brew’s temperature to at least 150 degrees for up to six hours.​

WINNER - The Technivorm assures you of consistent performance and results with every use, which makes it a clear winner in this category.


4. The Resulting Brew

The ingenious design of the Bonavita and Technivorm gives you coffee that can be both smooth and strong.

A lot of it has to do with the filters you use with both brewers too. Paper filters have finer holes, thus producing a smoother cup. Reusable filters on the other hand let more of coffee’s natural oils through.

Either way, it is important to pre-rinse the filter and your carafe too, to ensure that optimal temperature is reached and maintained during the brewing process.

WINNER - Both coffee makers deliver decent-tasting cups. Your choice of beans and filter, right grinding, and good water quality is what will largely affect the taste of your resulting brew. You must keep in mind though that automatic coffee makers don’t always deliver much in terms of flavor. They also end to reheat the brew repeatedly, which can eventually affect the taste.


THE VERDICT

The Bonavita and Technivorm offer coffee enthusiasts a means of getting a decent cup of joe within minutes, with just the touch of a button. They are also great for serving groups because of the multiple cups they can produce in one brewing session.

The affordable price tag that comes with the dependable features of the Bonavita definitely earns it plus points. However, when it comes to style and overall durability, it is edged out by the Technivorm.

The Technivorm’s main downside is its price of around $300. But with its efficient design, precise assembly, durable materials, and impressive brewing performance, you get a worthy investment that is built to last for years. If you drink one coffee each day for 3 years (it will last much longer, by the way) that’s 27c per use. Not bad.​

Bonavita BV1800SS 8-Cup Original Coffee Brewer

Bonavita BV1800SS 8-Cup Original Coffee Brewer, Stainless Steel

Moccamaster KBT 10-Cup Coffee Brewer with Thermal Carafe

If you want a great automated machine that delivers well without the price tag, go with the Bonavita. If you’re willing to invest in a brewer that will last you for years, the Technivorm is a worthy choice. And if you’re after something else, start here.

Keep in mind that these automatic drip brewers are more known for the convenience they offer rather than overall quality of the brew they produce. So, if quick and easy is what you need in your everyday coffee maker, then these two make for good options. Bonavita vs Technivorm – what will it be for you? Let us know in the comments below.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 3 comments
nina - May 5, 2017

I bought the Technivorm Mocamaster with Thermal carafe from William Sonoma and I agree with all the positive points mentioned BUT the the carafe doesn’t have a pour spout!!!!! and therefore be careful when pouring your coffee in your cup. Also the top portion of the carafe is NOT tilted into the main body of the reservoir meaning you will have a ring of the coffee standing on top of the carafe all the time and constantly you have to clean it off with a napkin ( if you are picky like me). Even the ladies at William Sonoma were surprised about it. Sadly I had to return it. Search goes on!

Reply
    Larry - May 6, 2017

    I have had this one for 8 years. It has never had this problem.

    Reply
Rocco - December 18, 2017

LOVE LOVE LOVE my Moccamaster. After 2 blessed years – do not know what I would do without it.

Reply

Leave a Reply: