The Mistobox Coffee Review

Let me guess: you’re thinking about getting a Mistobox coffee subscription?

One of the biggest problems when it comes to coffee subscriptions is that you can genuinely not know what you’re going to get. I mean, you might know it’ll be high-quality stuff...But is there any way to have more than just a few choices, most of which you’re not even sure you want to try?

You're about to read our Mistobox review and see if its the right choice for you.

MOST LOVED SUBSCRIPTIONS: The 2019 customer favourites are Atlas Coffee Club (overall winner) Driftaway coffee (for freshness) and Angels' Cup (for curiosity and excitement)

The MistoBox Coffee Review (Quick Version)

Mistobox Subscription Review
  • Quality of Coffee
  • Variety of Coffee
  • Freshness of Roast
  • Price
  • Customer Service/Care
4.5
Misto Box products and manual
Brown mistobox

The Mistobox coffee subscription brings you an incredible variety of coffees to choose from, flexible shipping, and even a personal coffee curator to help you understand the complex world of artisan coffee.

Their prices are affordable, and their site is informative. If you’re looking for a well-rounded and informed coffee subscription experience, this is where you want to be. Its a solid option, and often secures a place in the top 10 coffee subscription boxes (which you can check out here)


Before You Choose a Coffee Subscription, Consider This…

Now, before we get into the nitty-gritty details of Mistobox coffee, let’s slow down for a second and go over some of the key things to keep in mind when choosing a coffee subscription.

Frequency: Just How Much Coffee Do You Need?

It’s important to know how much you're drinking before you pick out a subscription. How many cups per day do you drink? How often do you buy new beans? Why do you need to know this?

Well, a lot of subscriptions have options for frequency of delivery. You don’t want to overpay for extra coffee that will go to waste or, even worse, run out of coffee because you didn’t get enough!

Understand Your “Coffee Knowledge”

Before you purchase a coffee subscription, you should know what your preferences are for things like roast type (light, medium, or dark?), flavor profiles (floral, citrusy, nutty?), and washing processes (dry, wet, pulped?).

Different types of roasted coffee beans

These preferences are generally the first thing you will be asked about when you sign up for a subscription...in most cases. Sometimes, the company will help you choose.

It’s important to gauge how well you understand the details of what you actually like when it comes to coffee.

Here’s a great article that breaks down these elements of coffee. You can use it to get a feel for your own understanding, and work out exactly what makes a certain coffee your favorite!

Shipping and the Cost

Keep an eye out for shipping costs with all subscriptions. For example, an offer of free shipping on your first order can disguise a large shipping cost in the future. And, of course, you need to understand your financial limitations.

Now, I think we can safely assume that if you’re looking for a subscription in the first place, you’re not thinking clearance level prices. Still, there is somewhat of a financial scale to coffee subscriptions, and the differences in price add up when purchased on a weekly or even a monthly basis.

Know your budget! Alright, now on to the Mistobox coffee review.

What Is The MistoBox Coffee Subscription?

Mistobox is a coffee subscription with an almost unbelievable amount of freedom and empowerment, particularly when it comes to their coffee selections. A Mistobox coffee subscription is the answer to any coffee fanatic who wants to try something new, while ensuring that the newness and variety will still be coming from types of coffee they prefer.

Mistobox works with over 50 artisan coffee roasters, which allows them to offer an incredible variety of coffees – literally, hundreds of them. You can start by getting their Mistobox discovery box, which is a few samples to help you narrow down your initial preferences.

After that, you’re off to the races. They roast each batch of coffee to order based on what they know you like, then pack it up in their nifty subscription boxes and then ship those Misto coffee boxes to you quickly.

Did we mention that they were on Shark Tank, too? Yeah, and Cuban made a deal with the company. I’d say that’s a pretty good endorsement. See the pitch that started it all: 

Our Full MistoBox Subscription Review

Misto Box products and manual
Brown mistobox

PROS

  • Incredible variety. There are hundreds of coffees available for each subscriber to discover.
  • A personally assigned coffee curator helps walk you through the process.
  • They have an easy-to-use system. You can change your preferences and coffee choices at the push of a button. 

CONS

  • Hit or miss customer service. Their rapid growth over the last few years has caused their earlier reputation of customer service to tarnish a bit.
  • While their prices are good, their shipping is a full $5 per shipment, keeping their overall price per bag slightly higher than many other options.

You’ll Drown in the Options (In a Good Way!)

Mistobox is the king of the castle when it comes to varieties of coffee offered. You get to choose from – get this – over 500 different options! And these aren’t just little unknown roasters, either. Their ranks include some pretty big shot names like Intelligentsia, Onyx, and Verve.

You can see the full line-up here. It’s pretty legit!

Organize their coffees by roast type, processing method, origin, tasting notes and more, to easily find the right ones for you. Simply add them to your “Brew Queue”, a nifty feature that acts almost like a music playlist.

As you browse and see coffees you would like to try, you can add them to the Brew Queue. Then, each shipment of coffee works its way down the queue. You can even rearrange the coffees within the queue if you can’t wait to get your hands on one further down your list.

If selecting your own coffee from such a huge assortment of options seems too overwhelming, though, don’t despair! Once your coffee preferences are set, you can also opt to have Mistobox choose for you. And I don’t mean some automated algorithm matching you to a random coffee that “fits your preferences.” I’m talking about the coffee curator...

A Coffee Curator Just For YOU

What is a coffee curator, you ask? 

Well, when you purchase a subscription, you are actually matched up with a living, breathing coffee curator, who will use their expertise to direct you towards the best coffee FOR YOU.

You can contact them with questions and discuss your coffee hopes, dreams, and desires in as much detail as you want.

While the actual customer service for Mistobox seems to have suffered a bit during their rapid growth, their coffee curator service still gets rave reviews everywhere you look! Now that is something that tips the scales in favor of this subscription.

The Mistobox Tiers: You’ve Got Pricing Options Here...

Mistobox offers two tiers to their subscription options: Basic and Deluxe.

Basic has one goal – to get you good coffee at an affordable price and on a regular basis.

Deluxe on the other hand, is more bent towards the coffee aficionados who want to up their game and keep trying the best of the best coffee out there. It’s a little bit more expensive, but it gets you access to a steady flow of the top specialty coffees that Mistobox has to offer.

Shipping and Coffee Quantity are in Your Hands

When it comes to shipping, Mistobox does charge $5 per shipment, so you’ll want to keep that in mind when you see the price per bag pop up on the screen. But, by all accounts, the shipping is fast, and it can ship on your schedule. You set up how often you want the coffee, from every week up to every four weeks.

As far as cost goes, you can sign up on a pay-per-month basis, or you can sign up for six or even twelve months at a time.

Their subscription comes in at around $20 per month after shipping on the pay-per-month plan, which is a reasonable amount for artisan coffee. Now, that’s the per month plan.  If you pay upfront for the whole year, though, it drops down to under $18 per box (again, that’s including shipping). That is a seriously affordable box of high-quality coffee, right there!

Coffee Information is Coffee Power… 

When it comes to artisan coffee, knowledge is a huge factor in how to get that perfect cup a joe. I mean, we’re not talking about instant coffee, here! Yuck!

But buying great coffee beans only gets you halfway there. You need info on brewing methods and how to prepare different kinds of coffees depending on origin, roast types, etc. We loved poking around the Mistobox website because it revealed just how serious they are about this end of things.

The site is a treasure trove of coffee information. Their blog is overflowing with great articles and reviews, and their Coffee Brew Guides page has videos on how to brew with a French press, Aeropress, Hario V60, and more. 

Check out their video on how to use a Chemex below!

Not Sold? 3 Other Options We Recommend.

I get it - Mistobox is not for everyone, and especially since the customer service has slipped a little. Here are 3 other winning options, based on customer feedback:

ATLAS COFFEE CLUB

When you sign up to Atlas coffee club, you go on world coffee tastebud tour. They will send you beans from exotic micro-lots around the world, and educate you on the coffee in the process. Everything from the local culture, to tasting notes, to the best way to brew.

> Read our Atlas Review

DRIFTAWAY COFFEE

The Driftaway coffee subscription keeps on winning customer awards, and its easy to see why. In simple terms, they help you find and choose amazing quality beans, for great prices, that are ethically sourced and insanely fresh. 

> Read our Driftaway Review

ANGELS CUP SUBSCRIPTION

If the hundreds of choices are just too overwhelming, consider signing up for an Angels’ Cup subscription. Each box contains blind tastings of various artisan coffees, and you can use their app to record the details and personal notes of each tasting, and join the conversation with a larger coffee community.

> Read our Angels' Cup Review

If you’re not happy with the other options consider Bean Box or the Stumptown coffee subscription - 2 more solid options.


MistoBox Review: THE VERDICT

We do a lot of coffee subscription reviews around here, so we can say with confidence that Mistobox is a GREAT option for a coffee subscription. They are well priced, offer quick and flexible shipping options, and have various tiers to their subscription.

Overall, I give them a 4/5. If you're unsure, however, Check out our reviews of the alternatives listed above: ATLAS, ANGELS CUP or DRIFTAWAY.  They are our current favourite picks.

Misto Box products and manual
Brown mistobox

But what really helps Mistobox stand apart from the pack are two things: their unbelievable variety of coffee choices, and the personally assigned coffee curators that each and every subscriber gets access to.

  • Alex
  • January 3, 2019
Alex
 

Alex is the Founder and Editor of Homegrounds.co. He is passionate about brewing amazing coffee at home, and teaching others to do the same.